Collective Blog

Accounting Advisory Conversations: Start With Why

Written by Blake Charman | Nov 9, 2026, 2:15:01 PM

Many firm owners hold back from advisory meetings because they worry they won’t know what to say. What if the client asks something you can’t answer? What value can you add beyond the financial statements?

Marilyn Melendez, EA, President of Dalia Tax & Business Advisors in West Palm Beach, Florida, has a different starting point. She opens each client relationship by asking why they do what they do. Her bilingual firm serves second-generation owners, women entrepreneurs, and Spanish-speaking owners new to doing business in the U.S. She makes a point of skipping technical jargon so clients understand their options.

Below, we’ll cover how to reframe the financials, which questions to ask, how to stay neutral with family businesses, and how choosing the right niche makes all of it easier. Prefer to watch? Here’s the full conversation. 

 

 

Treat the Financials as a Byproduct

The P&L, balance sheet, and tax return are the core of what accounting firms deliver. Marilyn doesn’t downplay them, but she frames them differently for her clients. “They’re not the goal. They’re not the purpose. They are a byproduct,” she says.

That shift changes the conversation. When the numbers are a tool rather than the point, you have room to talk about what the client is trying to build.

Start Every Advisory Conversation With the Client’s Why

Marilyn sits down with each client and asks about their motivation. Often the question is direct: “Why do you work the crazy hours?” Every client has their own story. She tells them, “I’m here to hear your story. Don’t think of me as just your accountant.”

Her reason is practical. Advice only helps if you and the client want the same outcome. “I can’t give you business strategy if my goal for you is growing, and your goal for you is making it more manageable,” she says. “We have to be in alignment.” A few questions can open that conversation:

  • What are you working toward? Growth, stability, an exit, or more time at home each call for different advice.
  • What are you sacrificing right now? The answer often reveals what matters most to them.
  • What would make the business feel more manageable? This helps you spot where your advice can make the biggest difference.

Let Clients Talk Their Way to an Answer

Rachel Dillon, who leads Dillon Business Advisors with Marcus Dillon, CPA, and co-founded Collective by DBA, says much of an advisor’s value comes from listening. “So much happens when someone just talks through something out loud,” she says. “So many times you don’t have to necessarily provide the answer. They almost arrive on their own. You just have to ask the questions.”

When clients hear their ideas out loud, they can tell which ones hold up. Your role is to guide that process and confirm what they’ve landed on. That takes some of the pressure off advisory meetings.

Be the Voice of the Business

Many of Marilyn’s clients are family businesses or husband-and-wife companies. In those settings, she often becomes a confidant. She’s clear with owners about her role: “I’m not there to serve them as individuals. I’m there to serve the wellbeing of the business.”

“I’m the voice of the business,” she says. That stance helps her stay neutral when owners disagree. It also gives clients a perspective they rarely get from a typical accountant.

She acknowledges this approach fits her personality. “I get people on planes telling me their life stories, and I’m like, ‘Really? Say more,’” she says. If you’re not someone who enjoys going deep with people, this style may not suit you, and that’s fine. You can still apply the core idea of advocating for the business as a whole.

Choose a Niche Where You Have Context

Advisory is easier when you understand the people you serve. Many owners assume that means picking an industry like dentistry or construction. Marilyn’s niche is built around a type of person instead. She serves owners facing the same challenges she lived through, especially second-generation owners taking over from a parent.

Rachel points out that people are often best equipped to help those who are where they once were. “We shouldn’t pigeonhole ourselves,” she says. Industry niches still make sense when specialized software or expertise is required. Even within an industry, you’ll still have an ideal client.

Marilyn has also learned which business size suits her style. Her sweet spot is companies with $1 million to $3 million in revenue and about 25 employees or fewer. When a company has too many layers of management, she can’t get close enough to the owner’s goals.

Once you know who you serve, Marcus says, marketing gets simpler. “This is who we’re best equipped for. You market to it, you talk about it,” he says, and that’s who you attract.

Celebrate When Clients Outgrow You

Some owners worry about losing clients as those businesses grow. Marilyn sees it as a sign her work succeeded. “I feel so proud when people outgrow me,” she says. Whether a client is ready for a bigger firm or ready to sell, she counts it as a win.

She doesn’t expect clients to stay forever out of loyalty. When someone suggested they should, her response was simple: “No, they don’t.” What matters to her is the progress they made together. “I was a part of their story,” she says.

Marcus sees a similar pattern at DBA. “Some of our best clients, they just become your friends,” he says. That kind of relationship is hard to replace, and it starts with caring about what the client wants.

Next Steps for Better Advisory Conversations

You can start using this approach in your next client meeting.

  • Ask one why question. Before you review the numbers, ask what the client is working toward.
  • Listen longer than feels natural. Let the client talk through a challenge before offering your view.
  • Clarify your role with family businesses. Tell owners you’re there to advocate for the business as a whole.
  • Look at your best clients. Note what they have in common beyond industry, such as stage, size, or ownership.

Get Help Building Your Advisory Practice

Starting advisory conversations is easier with a clear process and the right clients. Collective by DBA’s advisors can help you define your niche, structure client meetings, and build advisory into how your team serves clients. Schedule a call with Collective by DBA to talk through your plans.

If you'd rather start by learning alongside other firm owners, explore Collective by DBA membership. Members get access to a community of accounting firm leaders working through the same questions, plus templates, CPE-eligible webinars, and Streamlined OS to help them decide what to focus on first.